Proportional Reasoning - 2 | IT

Question 5

Try to find the distances between the same two pairs of cities with different maps that have different scales (ratios). Do they all give the same geographical distance, approximately?

Check your answer with HomiSolve it yourself, then let Homi check your steps and spot mistakes.
Solution
Understand the Question
  • A map scale represents the ratio between the distance on a map and the actual distance on the ground.
  • Formula: Actual Distance=Map Distance×Scale Factor\text{Actual Distance} = \text{Map Distance} \times \text{Scale Factor}
  • Even though different maps with different scales show different measured distances on paper for the same two cities, multiplying each map distance by its respective scale factor yields the same actual geographical distance (approximately, accounting for slight measurement error).

Step 1 · Measure Map Distances for Two Scales

Consider two maps showing the distance between the same two cities (Delhi and Jaipur):

  • Map A: Scale is 1:2,000,0001 : 2,000,000
  • Map B: Scale is 1:4,000,0001 : 4,000,000Diagram 1

Measuring the straight-line distance between the cities on each map:

  • Distance on Map A (DAD_A) =13.5 cm= 13.5 \text{ cm}
  • Distance on Map B (DBD_B) =6.75 cm= 6.75 \text{ cm}

Step 2 · Calculate Actual Geographical Distances

Using the formula: Actual Distance=Map Distance×Scale Factor\text{Actual Distance} = \text{Map Distance} \times \text{Scale Factor}

For Map A:

AA=DA×SA=13.5 cm×2,000,000=27,000,000 cm\begin{aligned} A_A &= D_A \times S_A \\ &= 13.5 \text{ cm} \times 2,000,000 \\ &= 27,000,000 \text{ cm} \end{aligned}

Converting to kilometers (1 km=100,000 cm1 \text{ km} = 100,000 \text{ cm}): AA=27,000,000100,000 km=270 kmA_A = \dfrac{27,000,000}{100,000} \text{ km} = 270 \text{ km}

For Map B:

AB=DB×SB=6.75 cm×4,000,000=27,000,000 cm\begin{aligned} A_B &= D_B \times S_B \\ &= 6.75 \text{ cm} \times 4,000,000 \\ &= 27,000,000 \text{ cm} \end{aligned}

Converting to kilometers: AB=27,000,000100,000 km=270 kmA_B = \dfrac{27,000,000}{100,000} \text{ km} = 270 \text{ km}

Step 3 · Compare the Calculated Distances

Comparing the results:

  • Actual distance from Map A =270 km= 270 \text{ km}
  • Actual distance from Map B =270 km= 270 \text{ km}

Both calculations yield the same actual geographical distance.

Answer

Yes, they all give the same geographical distance, approximately.

Common Mistakes
  • Unit Conversion Error: Forgetting to convert centimeters to kilometers (1 km=100,000 cm1 \text{ km} = 100,000 \text{ cm}). Leaving the answer in centimeters can lead to confusion.
  • Operation Inversion: Dividing by the scale factor instead of multiplying when converting from map distance to actual real-world distance.

More questions in IT

Q1

Viswanath made idlis by mixing 6 cups of rice with 3 cups of urad dal, while Puneet made idlis by mixing 4 cups of rice with 2 cups of urad dal. If cooked in the same way, would their idlis taste the same?

Q2

Have you noticed that in many maps there is a ratio given, usually in the lower right corner of the map? It usually contains 11 and a very large number, such as 1:60,00,0001 : 60,00,000. What does RF 1:60,00,000\text{RF } 1 : 60,00,000 mean? What does it indicate? Can you guess?

Q3

Convert 60,00,000 cm60,00,000 \text{ cm} to kilometres.

It is 60 km60 \text{ km}. Verify this.

Q4

Using the map above, can you find the geographical distance between Bengaluru and Chennai? Also, find the geographical distance between Mangaluru and Chennai.

[Hint: Use a ruler to find the distance between the cities on the map. Then, use the ratio given on the map to find the actual geographical distance.]

Q5

Try to find the distances between the same two pairs of cities with different maps that have different scales (ratios). Do they all give the same geographical distance, approximately?

Q6

Context: Puneeth's father went from Lucknow to Kanpur in 3 hours by riding his motorcycle at a speed of 30 km/h. If he takes a car instead and drives at 60 km/h, how long will it take him to reach Kanpur?

Q. Can we represent this problem with the following statement of proportionality — 30:60::3:x30 : 60 :: 3 : x? Will the travel time increase or decrease as the speed of the motorcycle increases?

← Back to Proportional Reasoning - 2