The World of Numbers | Exercise 3.5

Question 4

The number 0.90.\overline{9} (which means 0.999990.99999\dots) is a rational number. Using algebra (let x=0.9x = 0.\overline{9}, multiply by 10, and subtract), explain why 0.90.\overline{9} is exactly equal to 1.

Check your answer with HomiSolve it yourself, then let Homi check your steps and spot mistakes.
Solution
Understand the Question
  • To express a repeating decimal as a fraction or integer, we define it as a variable x=0.9=0.99999x = 0.\overline{9} = 0.99999\dots
  • Since only one digit repeats, multiplying both sides by 1010 shifts the decimal point by one place.
  • Subtracting the original equation from this new equation eliminates the infinite repeating decimal portion completely, allowing us to solve directly for xx.

Step 1 · Define the Variable and Multiply by 10

Let x=0.99999(1)x = 0.99999\dots \quad \dots (1)

Multiplying both sides by 1010

10×x=10×0.9999910x=9.99999(2)\begin{aligned} 10 \times x &= 10 \times 0.99999\dots \\[0.6em] 10x &= 9.99999\dots \quad \dots (2) \end{aligned}

Step 2 · Subtract the Equations to Solve for xx

Subtracting equation (1)(1) from equation (2)(2)

10xx=9.999990.999999x=9x=99x=1\begin{aligned} 10x - x &= 9.99999\dots - 0.99999\dots \\[0.6em] 9x &= 9 \\[0.6em] x &= \dfrac{9}{9} \\[0.6em] x &= 1 \end{aligned}

Since x=0.9x = 0.\overline{9} and x=1x = 1, it follows that 0.9=10.\overline{9} = 1.

Answer

0.9=10.\overline{9} = 1

Common Mistakes
  • Intuition vs. Mathematical Equivalence: Assuming 0.90.\overline{9} is just "infinitely close to 11" rather than strictly equal. In the real number system, 0.90.\overline{9} and 11 represent the exact same quantity.
  • Decimal Place Error: Incorrectly thinking that shifting by 1010 leaves fewer 99s behind the decimal point; because the sequence is infinite, the non-terminating tails are identical and cancel out to zero.

More questions in Exercise 3.5

Q1

Without performing long division, determine which of the following rational numbers will have terminating decimals and which will be repeating: 720\dfrac{7}{20}, 415\dfrac{4}{15} and 13250\dfrac{13}{250}. Then check your answers by explicitly performing the long divisions and expressing these rational numbers as decimals.

Q2

Perform the long division for 113\dfrac{1}{13}. Identify the repeating block of digits. Does it show cyclic properties if you evaluate 213\dfrac{2}{13}? Now compute 313\dfrac{3}{13}, 413\dfrac{4}{13}, etc. What do you notice?

Q3

Classify the following numbers as rational or irrational:

(i) 81\sqrt{81}

(ii) 12\sqrt{12}

(iii) 0.333330.33333 \dots

(iv) 0.1234512345123450.123451234512345 \dots

(v) 1.010010001000011.01001000100001 \dots (Notice the pattern: Is it repeating a single block?)

(vi) 23.56018561223987479012023.560185612239874790120

Find the explicit fractions in case they are rational.

Q4

The number 0.90.\overline{9} (which means 0.999990.99999\dots) is a rational number. Using algebra (let x=0.9x = 0.\overline{9}, multiply by 10, and subtract), explain why 0.90.\overline{9} is exactly equal to 1.

Q5

*5. We have seen that the repeating block of 17\dfrac{1}{7} is a cyclic number. Try to find more numbers (nn) whose reciprocals (1n\dfrac{1}{n}) produce decimals with repeating blocks that are cyclic.

← Back to The World of Numbers