Fractals and Visualising Solids | A

Question 2

Cut off the four corners of an imaginary square, with each cut going between midpoints of adjacent edges. What shape is left over? How can you reassemble the four corners to make another square?

Check your answer with HomiSolve it yourself, then let Homi check your steps and spot mistakes.
Solution

We will find the shape left over after the cuts and then show how to reassemble the cut-off corners into a new square.

Step 1 — The shape left over

Let us imagine a square named ABCD. Let the side length of this square be 2x2x units. We find the midpoints of each side. Let P be the midpoint of side AB. Let Q be the midpoint of side BC. Let R be the midpoint of side CD. Let S be the midpoint of side DA. This means that AP = PB = BQ = QC = CR = RD = DS = SA = xx units. The problem says we cut between midpoints of adjacent edges. So, we cut along the lines PQ, QR, RS, and SP. The shape left in the middle is PQRS. Let us look at the triangle PBQ. Angle B in the square ABCD is a right angle (90 degrees). So, triangle PBQ is a right-angled triangle. Its sides PB and BQ are both xx units long. We can find the length of the cut line PQ using the Pythagoras theorem. The Pythagoras theorem states that in a right-angled triangle, the square of the hypotenuse (the side opposite the right angle) is equal to the sum of the squares of the other two sides.

PQ2=PB2+BQ2PQ^2 = PB^2 + BQ^2

PQ2=x2+x2PQ^2 = x^2 + x^2

PQ2=2x2PQ^2 = 2x^2

PQ=2x2PQ = \sqrt{2x^2}

PQ=x2 units\boxed{PQ = x\sqrt{2} \text{ units}}

All four triangles at the corners (AP S, PBQ, QCR, RDS) are identical. So, all four cut lines (PQ, QR, RS, SP) will have the same length. Therefore, PQ = QR = RS = SP = x2x\sqrt{2} units. This means the shape PQRS has four equal sides. It is a rhombus. Now, let us check the angles of PQRS. Consider triangle AP S. Angle A is 90 degrees. AP = AS = xx. This means triangle AP S is an isosceles right-angled triangle. The angles opposite the equal sides must be equal. So, Angle APS = Angle ASP = (18090)/2=45(180 - 90) / 2 = 45 degrees. Similarly, in triangle PBQ, Angle BPQ = 45 degrees. The line segment AB is a straight line. Angle SPQ is formed by parts of this line. Angle SPQ = 180 degrees - Angle APS - Angle BPQ

=1804545= 180^\circ - 45^\circ - 45^\circ

=90= 90^\circ

All four angles of PQRS are 90 degrees. Since PQRS has four equal sides and four right angles, it is a square.

Diagram 1

Step 2 — The cut-off corners

The four cut-off corner pieces are the triangles AP S, PBQ, QCR, and RDS. Each of these is a right-angled isosceles triangle. Each triangle has two shorter sides (legs) of length xx units. Each triangle has one longer side (hypotenuse) of length x2x\sqrt{2} units. All four triangles are identical in shape and size. The area of one such triangle is half times base times height.

Area of one triangle=12×x×x\text{Area of one triangle} = \frac{1}{2} \times x \times x

Area of one triangle=x22 square units\boxed{\text{Area of one triangle} = \frac{x^2}{2} \text{ square units}}

The total area of the four corner triangles is 4×(x2/2)=2x24 \times (x^2/2) = 2x^2 square units. The area of the central square PQRS is (side length)2=(x2)2=2x2(\text{side length})^2 = (x\sqrt{2})^2 = 2x^2 square units. This shows that the total area of the cut-off corners is exactly the same as the area of the central square.

Step 3 — Reassembling the corners

We can reassemble the four identical right-angled isosceles triangles to form another square. To do this, we arrange the four triangles such that their right-angle vertices (A, B, C, D from the original square) all meet at a single central point. Let's imagine this central point is O. Each triangle has legs of length xx units. When the four right-angle vertices meet at O, the legs of the triangles will extend outwards from O. For example, one leg of triangle AP S will point along the positive x-axis for xx units. Its other leg will point along the positive y-axis for xx units. The hypotenuses of the four triangles will then form the outer boundary of the new square. The corners of this new square will be the endpoints of these legs. These endpoints are at a distance of xx units from the center O along four different directions (like the points (x,0)(x,0), (0,x)(0,x), (x,0)(-x,0), (0,x)(0,-x) on a graph). The side length of this new square is the distance between two adjacent corners, for example, between the point (x,0)(x,0) and (0,x)(0,x). Using the distance formula (which is like Pythagoras theorem on a coordinate plane):

Side length of new square=(x0)2+(0x)2\text{Side length of new square} = \sqrt{(x-0)^2 + (0-x)^2}

=x2+(x)2= \sqrt{x^2 + (-x)^2}

=x2+x2= \sqrt{x^2 + x^2}

=2x2= \sqrt{2x^2}

Side length of new square=x2 units\boxed{\text{Side length of new square} = x\sqrt{2} \text{ units}}

This new square has a side length of x2x\sqrt{2} units. In Step 1, we found that the central square PQRS also has a side length of x2x\sqrt{2} units. Since both squares have the same side length, they are of the same size.

Diagram 2

Answer

(i) The shape left over is a square. (ii) The four corners are identical right-angled isosceles triangles. (iii) We can reassemble the four corner triangles to make another square by placing their right-angle vertices together at a central point. This new square will be of the same size as the central square.

More questions in A

Q1

Build it in Your Imagination

We will start this section by practising visualisation. For each prompt, feel free to talk to your partner, gesture, draw it in the air — but do not actually draw on paper!

  1. Picture your name, then read off the letters backwards. Make sure to do this by sight, not by sound — really see your name! Now try with your friend's name.
Q2

Cut off the four corners of an imaginary square, with each cut going between midpoints of adjacent edges. What shape is left over? How can you reassemble the four corners to make another square?

Q3

Mark the sides of an equilateral triangle into thirds. Cut off each corner of the triangle, as far as the marks. What shape do you get?

Q4

Mark the sides of a square into thirds and cut off each of its corners as far as the marks. What shape is left?

Q5

Net of a sphere? Experiment and see if you can make a paper cutout that can perfectly wrap around a ball without leaving any wrinkles, gaps or overlaps.

Q6

Place an object in front of a plane, such as a wall of your room. Shine a torch light on the object in a direction perpendicular to the wall.

What do you see?

Q7

Observe what happens to the size of the shadow as you vary the distance between your torch and your object.

Q8

Context: Observe what happens to the size of the shadow as you vary the distance between your torch and your object.

Q. Why does this happen?

Q9

Construct a model of a cube and use your hands to keep it balanced on one corner vertex. Can you try to understand why all the projected edges have equal length?

← Back to Fractals and Visualising Solids