Connecting the Dots… | A

Question 3

Connect the Dots...

A number lock has a 3-digit code. Find the code using the hints below.

Question diagram 1
Check your answer with HomiSolve it yourself, then let Homi check your steps and spot mistakes.
Solution

We will use the given hints to find the three-digit code for the lock.

Step 1 — Eliminate impossible digits

We first look at the hint that says "Nothing is correct". The hint "0 3 6 - Nothing is correct" means these digits are not in the code. So, the digits 0, 3, and 6 are not part of the secret code. Let the code be P1P2P3P_1 P_2 P_3. P1,P2,P3{0,3,6}P_1, P_2, P_3 \notin \{0, 3, 6\}

Diagram 1

Step 2 — Identify a certain digit and its position rule

Next, we use the hint "0 6 4 - One digit is correct but wrongly placed". We already know that 0 and 6 are not in the code from Step 1. So, the only possible correct digit from "0 6 4" must be 4. This digit 4 is in the second position in "0 6 4". The hint says this digit is wrongly placed. So, 4 is in the code, but it is not in the second position. 4 is in the code4 \text{ is in the code} P24P_2 \neq 4

Step 3 — Deduce more digits and their positions

Now we use the hint "5 4 2 - Two digits are correct but wrongly placed". We know from Step 2 that 4 is in the code. So, 4 is one of the two correct digits in this hint. The other correct digit must be either 5 or 2. Also, all correct digits in this hint are wrongly placed.

Let us consider two possibilities for the second correct digit:

Possibility A: The correct digits are 4 and 5. This means that 2 is NOT in the code. Let us check Hint 1: "2 6 5 - One digit is correct and well placed". We know 2 is not in the code, and 6 is not in the code (from Step 1). So, 5 must be the correct and well-placed digit. This means P3=5P_3 = 5. However, from Hint 3, if 5 is a correct digit, it must be wrongly placed. This means P15P_1 \neq 5, P25P_2 \neq 5, and P35P_3 \neq 5. This contradicts our finding that P3=5P_3 = 5. So, Possibility A is incorrect.

Possibility B: The correct digits are 4 and 2. This means that 5 is NOT in the code. Let us check Hint 1: "2 6 5 - One digit is correct and well placed". We know 6 is not in the code (from Step 1), and 5 is not in the code (from this possibility). So, 2 must be the correct and well-placed digit. This means P1=2P_1 = 2. Now, let us check this with Hint 3 ("5 4 2 - Two digits are correct but wrongly placed"). The correct digits are 4 and 2. They are both wrongly placed. For 4: P24P_2 \neq 4. This is consistent with Step 2. For 2: P32P_3 \neq 2. We have P1=2P_1 = 2. This does not contradict P32P_3 \neq 2. So, Possibility B is consistent.

From this step, we have found:

  • 5 is NOT in the code.
  • 2 IS in the code.
  • P1=2P_1 = 2.
  • P32P_3 \neq 2.

Step 4 — Place the third digit

We know the first digit of the code is 2 (P1=2P_1 = 2). We also know that 4 is in the code, and P24P_2 \neq 4 (from Step 2). Since P1=2P_1 = 2, 4 cannot be P1P_1. Since P24P_2 \neq 4, 4 cannot be P2P_2. So, 4 must be in the third position. P3=4P_3 = 4 We now have the first and third digits of the code: 2 _ 4. We also confirmed P32P_3 \neq 2 because 424 \neq 2.

Step 5 — Find the middle digit

We need to find the digit for P2P_2. The digits not in the code are 0, 3, 5, 6. The digits we have placed are P1=2P_1 = 2 and P3=4P_3 = 4. So, P2P_2 must be one of the remaining digits: {1, 7, 8, 9}.

Let us use the hint "2 7 1 - One digit is correct but wrongly placed". We know 2 is in the code (P1=2P_1 = 2). If 2 was the correct digit from "2 7 1", it would have to be wrongly placed. But 2 is in the first position in "2 7 1", and P1=2P_1 = 2. So 2 is well placed. Therefore, 2 is not the "one digit correct but wrongly placed" from this hint. This means the correct digit from "2 7 1" must be either 7 or 1. And it must be wrongly placed.

Let us check if 7 is the correct digit. If 7 is correct, it must be wrongly placed. 7 is in the second position in "2 7 1". So, P27P_2 \neq 7. If 7 is in the code, it must be P1=7P_1=7 or P3=7P_3=7. But we know P1=2P_1 = 2 and P3=4P_3 = 4. So, 7 cannot be in the code.

Let us check if 1 is the correct digit. If 1 is correct, it must be wrongly placed. 1 is in the third position in "2 7 1". So, P31P_3 \neq 1. We know P3=4P_3 = 4, so P31P_3 \neq 1 is true. Since 1 is in the code, and P1=2P_1 = 2 and P3=4P_3 = 4, 1 must be P2P_2. So, the middle digit is 1. P2=1P_2 = 1

The code is 2 1 4.

Answer

The 3-digit code is 214.

More questions in A

Q1

How long is a minute?

Two groups of children were asked to estimate the length of 1 minute. They start by closing their eyes and then open them when they think 1 minute has passed. Of course, they are not supposed to count while their eyes are closed. The dot plots below show after how many seconds the children opened their eyes.

Discuss how well both the groups fared at this activity. Describe and compare the variability in data and their central tendency.

Q2

Spend sufficient time observing the data presented in this table. Share your findings with the class.

These are some prompts for you to probe —

  • Changes in the heights of boys or girls of a certain age from 1989 to 2019.
  • The heights of boys vs. girls at different ages in a particular year.
  • Changes in height between successive ages in boys and girls in 2019.
Q3

Connect the Dots...

A number lock has a 3-digit code. Find the code using the hints below.

← Back to Connecting the Dots…