A Tale of Three Intersecting Lines | A

Question 3

Shortest Path in a Box!

There is a spider in a corner of a box. It wants to reach the farthest opposite corner (marked in the figure). Since it cannot fly, it can reach the opposite point only by walking on the surfaces of the box. What is the shortest path it can take?

Take a cardboard box and mark the path that you think is the shortest from one corner to its opposite corner. Compare the length of this path with that of the paths made by your friends.

Hint:

Question diagram 1
Check your answer with HomiSolve it yourself, then let Homi check your steps and spot mistakes.
Solution

The shortest path on the box is a straight line on its net.

Step 1 — Define the Box

Let us imagine a rectangular box. Let its length be LL. Let its width be WW. Let its height be HH. The spider starts at one corner. It wants to reach the farthest opposite corner.

Diagram 1

Step 2 — Unfold the Box

The spider must walk on the box surfaces. It cannot fly through the air. To find the shortest path, we flatten the box. We unfold two adjacent faces of the box. These faces must connect the start and end corners. This unfolding creates a flat rectangle. The shortest path is a straight line across this rectangle. We use the Pythagorean theorem to find its length.

Step 3 — Calculate Path Options

There are three main ways to unfold two faces. Each way connects the opposite corners. Let us calculate the length for each way.

Path Option 1: Across the length and height faces. We unfold the 'front' face and the 'top' face. They share a common length LL. The new rectangle has length LL. Its width is the sum of height and width. This sum is H+WH+W. Let P1P_1 be the length of this path.

P1=L2+(H+W)2P_1 = \sqrt{L^2 + (H+W)^2}

Path Option 2: Across the length and width faces. We unfold the 'front' face and a 'side' face. They share a common height HH. The new rectangle has height HH. Its length is the sum of length and width. This sum is L+WL+W. Let P2P_2 be the length of this path.

P2=(L+W)2+H2P_2 = \sqrt{(L+W)^2 + H^2}

Path Option 3: Across the width and height faces. We unfold the 'bottom' face and a 'side' face. They share a common width WW. The new rectangle has width WW. Its length is the sum of length and height. This sum is L+HL+H. Let P3P_3 be the length of this path.

P3=(L+H)2+W2P_3 = \sqrt{(L+H)^2 + W^2}

Step 4 — Find the Shortest Path Length

The shortest path is the smallest of these three values. We need to compare P1P_1, P2P_2, and P3P_3. The smallest value is the shortest path length. Let us use an example. Suppose the box has dimensions: Length L=4L = \mathbf{4} units. Width W=3W = \mathbf{3} units. Height H=2H = \mathbf{2} units.

Let us calculate P1P_1. P1=42+(2+3)2P_1 = \sqrt{4^2 + (2+3)^2} =16+52= \sqrt{16 + 5^2} =16+25= \sqrt{16 + 25} =41= \sqrt{41}

6.40 units\boxed{\approx \mathbf{6.40} \text{ units}}

Let us calculate P2P_2. P2=(4+3)2+22P_2 = \sqrt{(4+3)^2 + 2^2} =72+4= \sqrt{7^2 + 4} =49+4= \sqrt{49 + 4} =53= \sqrt{53}

7.28 units\boxed{\approx \mathbf{7.28} \text{ units}}

Let us calculate P3P_3. P3=(4+2)2+32P_3 = \sqrt{(4+2)^2 + 3^2} =62+9= \sqrt{6^2 + 9} =36+9= \sqrt{36 + 9} =45= \sqrt{45}

6.71 units\boxed{\approx \mathbf{6.71} \text{ units}}

Comparing the three path lengths: P16.40P_1 \approx \mathbf{6.40} units. P27.28P_2 \approx \mathbf{7.28} units. P36.71P_3 \approx \mathbf{6.71} units. The shortest path for this box is P1P_1.

Answer

(i) The shortest path is found by unfolding two adjacent faces of the box. (ii) These faces must connect the starting corner to the farthest opposite corner. (iii) The path is a straight line drawn across this unfolded flat rectangle. (iv) Its length is calculated using the Pythagorean theorem. (v) The shortest path length is the minimum of L2+(H+W)2\sqrt{L^2 + (H+W)^2}, (L+W)2+H2\sqrt{(L+W)^2 + H^2}, and (L+H)2+W2\sqrt{(L+H)^2 + W^2}.

More questions in A

Q2

Cut out a paper triangle. Fix one of the sides as the base. Fold it in such a way that the resulting crease is an altitude from the top vertex to the base. Justify why the crease formed should be perpendicular to the base.

Q3

Shortest Path in a Box!

There is a spider in a corner of a box. It wants to reach the farthest opposite corner (marked in the figure). Since it cannot fly, it can reach the opposite point only by walking on the surfaces of the box. What is the shortest path it can take?

Take a cardboard box and mark the path that you think is the shortest from one corner to its opposite corner. Compare the length of this path with that of the paths made by your friends.

Hint:

← Back to A Tale of Three Intersecting Lines